©-LAW

Article 17 of the Copyright DSM Directive and the InfoSoc Directive: a special relationship? What is the legal nature of Article 17 of the  Copyright DSM Directive ? What is the relationship InfoSoc Directive ? between that provision and the  These questions, which  might  look at first sight academic in both nature and significance, are actually of great practical relevance, including to determine the room for manoeuvre enjoyed by EU Member States during the (ongoing) national transposition phase. In this sense, it is notable that the German Government has been moving from the idea that the freedom accorded under Article 17 is such that Member States are inter alia entitled to decide whether to introduce exceptions or limitations beyond  both  those specifically referred to in Article 17(7)  and  those listed in Article 5 of the InfoSoc Directive (see the proposed ‘de minimis’ remunerated ‘authorized use’ in  §6 of the German Discussion Draft Act ). The different vi