Posts

Showing posts with the label Syed C-572/17; Article 4 InfoSoc Directive; right of distribution; CJEU; EU copyright; AG Campos; counterfeits; CJEU; EU copyright; Dimensione Direct Sale; high level of protection

CJEU rules that warehouse storage of counterfeits due for sale falls within scope of distribution right

Image
Gamla stan in Stockholm, where the defendant's business was located Back in October The IPKat  reported  that in  Syed , C-572/17  Advocate General (AG)  Campos Sánchez-Bordona  had advised  the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to rule that the warehouse storage of copyright-infringing items due to be issued to the public is to be considered as an act falling within the scope of the right of distribution within Article 4 of the  InfoSoc Directive . Personally I thought and wrote that, in light of existing CJEU case law on the right of distribution - notably the decision in  Dimensione Direct Sales   [Katposts  here ]  -, the AG Opinion was not at all surprising. Yesterday, after less than 3 months, the CJEU issued its   judgment , which endorses the Opinion of AG Campos. Let's see how the Court reasoned. Concept of 'distribution' The CJEU started by noting the the concept of 'distribution' wit...